How They Built the Square: the Lincoln County Courthouse

Fayetteville’s square has had three courthouses before today’s: a $35 log cabin in 1811, a brick courthouse the next year, and an 1870s brick courthouse with a 150-foot clock tower. Here is who built them, what they cost, what they were made of, and how people put up brick buildings with no power tools.

Each county seat around here did the same thing in the same order: hold court in somebody’s house, put up a quick log courthouse, replace it with brick as soon as the county could pay, then rebuild after fire, storm or war. The county court picked a building committee, the committee drew up or approved plans, and a contractor bid the job. The names that come down to us are the committee members and contractors. The people who molded the brick and carried the hod mostly went unrecorded.

Lincoln County · Fayetteville

Lincoln County Courthouse

Every courthouse on the site

1. 1809–11 house Court first meets at the house of Brice M. Garner, who was paid $15 for the use of it. [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772]
2. 1811 log A temporary log courthouse, 18 by 20 feet, "built with round logs" and "covered with a good cabin roof," on one corner of the square. James Fuller built it for $35. [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772]
3. 1811–12 brick In November 1811 Micajah and William McElroy took the contract for a two-story brick courthouse for $3,995. The court later added $750, for a total of $4,745. The NRHP says brick buildings had replaced the log ones "by 1812." [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772] [NRHP 84003580, Sec. 8]
4. 1862–65 brick Union troops used the courthouse as a stable and as a fort, ringed by a brick "bomb proof" wall about six feet high. It was not burned. [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 777]
5. 1873 brick The 1811–12 brick courthouse is torn down (worn out, not burned). [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772] [NRHP 84003580, Sec. 8]
6. 1870s brick Third courthouse: an "Eclectic brick structure" with a tall central clock tower, built by William T. Moyers, James N. Allbright and William E. Turley for $39,579.30. [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772] [NRHP 84003580, Sec. 8]
7. c. 1970 today The 1870s building is torn down and replaced by today's courthouse. The National Register nomination says this happened in 1971 and calls the new building Georgian-style; the Tennessee Encyclopedia says it was built in 1970 and calls it Colonial Revival. [NRHP 84003580, Sec. 8] [Tennessee Encyclopedia]

Plans	A committee of J. H. Holman, H. C. Cowan and John Y. Gill reported the plans, specifications and estimates. [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772]
Superintendent	Theodore Harris superintended the work. [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772]
Materials	Brick walls. The 1887 Sanborn map shows it as two-story brick in a cross plan, with a "150' tower" and "clock" at the center. [Sanborn map, Fayetteville 1887]
Nearby stonework	The county jail of 1868 was "of stone," at a cost of not more than $33,000. The 1861 limestone bridge over the Elk River cost about $40,000. [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772]

Open questions. Goodspeed doesn't give the year the third courthouse was finished. Some web sources say 1873, others 1874, and only weak web sources name an architect (W. J. Davidson) and a stonemason (L. Pench & Co.). Some sources give 1815 for the brick courthouse. We use the NRHP's "by 1812" until a county record settles it. We also can’t yet date the change to today’s courthouse: the NRHP nomination says the old one was torn down and replaced in 1971, the Tennessee Encyclopedia says the new one was built in 1970, and courthouses.co gives 1969–71 without a source. County court minutes, a cornerstone or an Elk Valley Times story would settle it, and would also show whether the new building went up beside the old one or after it came down.

How builders worked in the 1800s

What follows is the same for all four of our county seats: Fayetteville, Shelbyville, Lynchburg and Pulaski.

Brick made on the spot

There was no brick factory to order from in 1811. When a county let a contract for a "brick court house," the builder usually made the brick near the site from local clay. Workers dug the clay, worked it with water until it was smooth, pressed it into wooden molds, and set the "green" bricks out in rows to dry in the sun. ["Brick making as a local industry in antebellum KY and TN"] [Miller, "Brick clamps," Contrebis]

Then came the firing. Instead of a permanent kiln, early brickmakers often built a clamp: the dried bricks themselves were stacked into a big block with tunnels at the bottom for the fire, and the outside was daubed over with mud to hold in the heat. The fire burned for days. Bricks near the fire came out hard and dark, sometimes glazed; bricks on the outside came out soft and pale. When it cooled, the clamp was taken apart and the bricks sorted, the hard ones for outside walls and the soft ones for inside. Archaeologists have dug up the remains of clamps like this in Kentucky and at Ames Plantation in West Tennessee. [Miller, "Brick clamps," Contrebis] [tDAR, Kentucky brick clamp report] [tDAR, Ames Plantation brick clamp]

That's why the brick in an old Tennessee wall varies so much in color and size. Every batch was a little different. ["Brick making as a local industry in antebellum KY and TN"]

Who did the work

For our four courthouses the records name contractors and committees: the McElroys and Fuller in Fayetteville, Archibald Alexander in Pulaski, S. L. P. Garrett in Lynchburg. We have not found any record that names the people who made the brick or laid the walls, so we don't guess. [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772] [Goodspeed 1886, Giles, pp. 754-755] [Goodspeed 1886, Moore, p. 809]

Records elsewhere in Tennessee show who could have done this kind of work:

• Enslaved workers. Enslaved people worked the brick kilns at Andrew Jackson's Hermitage. ["Brick making as a local industry in antebellum KY and TN"] When the State Capitol was started, the state rented fifteen enslaved men from A. G. Payne between spring 1846 and January 1847 to break and haul the limestone and cut the cellar. Twelve of their names are known: Lewis, Daniel, Robert, Nelson, John, Parker, Dang, Bill, John G., John, Andrew and Jim. Payne was paid $18 a month for each man. [TN House Joint Res. 152, 114th Gen. Assembly] [TSLA, Capitol construction records]
• Prisoners and paid craftsmen. The Capitol also used convict labor to quarry stone, and it hired skilled stonecutters. A docket of July 10, 1854 lists fifty-two of them, including Irish, German and Black workers. [TN House Joint Res. 318, 114th Gen. Assembly]
• Free Black tradesmen. Isaac Dockery, a free-born African American brickmaker, made the brick for the 1896 Sevier County Courthouse. [Tennessee Encyclopedia, Isaac Dockery]

Before the Civil War, Middle Tennessee had more enslaved people than any other part of the state. In towns, enslaved workers did most of the hard labor and much of the skilled work, and enslaved carpenters and other craftsmen were often hired out to other people. [Tennessee Encyclopedia, Slavery] So it's quite possible enslaved people helped build the early brick courthouses here. Until a county record, contract or account book says so, though, we're treating that as an open question.

Lime mortar, thick walls and limestone footings

Mortar. Builders made it from lime, sand and water. Limestone was burned to make quicklime, then "slaked" with water into a putty that was often aged for weeks or longer, then mixed with roughly three parts sand. Lime mortar stays a little soft, so the wall can move without cracking the brick. Portland cement was first made in the U.S. in 1872 and didn't become common until the early 1900s. Repointing an old wall with hard cement mortar can damage the brick. [NPS Preservation Brief 2]

Thick walls. With no steel frame, the brick walls held up the floors and roof by themselves, so they had to be thick, especially at the bottom. Lynchburg's courthouse walls are twenty inches thick. [NRHP 79002452 (Moore Co. Courthouse & Jail)]

Stone underneath. Middle Tennessee sits on limestone, and builders used it for footings and foundations. Lynchburg's courthouse and jail rest on "cut and coursed" limestone. Shelbyville's 1873 courthouse had a "rock foundation" and porch pillars of blue limestone. Fayetteville built a stone jail in 1868 and a limestone bridge across the Elk in 1861. [NRHP 79002452 (Moore Co. Courthouse & Jail)] [Goodspeed 1887, Bedford, pp. 865-867] [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772]

Timber: hewn by hand, then sawn by steam

The first public buildings went up from the trees at hand. Fayetteville's 1811 courthouse was "built with round logs." Its 1810 jail used logs "not less than twelve inches in diameter." Pulaski's 1811 courthouse was round logs "covered with boards." [Goodspeed 1886, Lincoln, p. 772] [Goodspeed 1886, Giles, pp. 754-755] To square a log, a worker scored it with an axe and then hewed the sides flat with a broadaxe and adze. You can still see the marks on old beams. [NPS Preservation Brief 26]

By the 1880s, steam mills had changed that. The 1887 Sanborn map shows Ryall Bros. running a saw mill and planing mill on the Duck River at Shelbyville. The 1888 map shows T. W. Pitman & Co. in Pulaski making sashes, doors and blinds. Floor joists, rafters, window frames and trim now came from the mill, not the broadaxe. [Sanborn map, Shelbyville 1887] [Sanborn map, Pulaski 1888] The wooden parts of brick buildings, like floors, roofs and towers, were also what burned. Sanborn maps mark the courthouse towers in Fayetteville and Pulaski in yellow, for wood. [Sanborn map, Fayetteville 1887] [Sanborn map, Pulaski 1888]

Iron and mail-order storefronts

Look at the ground floor of an old store on the square: big show windows set between slim iron columns. Cast iron could carry the upper brick walls on narrow posts, which left room for glass. Foundries sold the parts ready-made, so they took little work on site, and they stayed popular into the 1920s. [NPS Preservation Brief 27] Shelbyville's 1873 courthouse used cast-iron Corinthian pillars on its upper porches. [Goodspeed 1887, Bedford, pp. 865-867] Pulaski's NRHP nomination notes cast-iron pilasters on stores on North First Street. [NRHP 83003033]

Mesker fronts. From the 1880s through the 1910s, the Mesker companies of St. Louis and Evansville sold whole storefronts by catalog. Their pressed sheet-metal cornices and window heads were light enough to ship anywhere by rail, and the companies mailed out about 500,000 catalogs a year. [NPS, the Mesker brothers] The Mesker Brothers database lists these fronts in our towns: [Mesker Brothers database, Tennessee list]

• Fayetteville: Mesker Brothers fronts at 125, 127 (Post Office) and 129 E. Market St., and at the NW corner of College & Elk.
• Shelbyville: George L. Mesker & Co. at 115–121 Public Square South (a 1905 catalog testimonial). Mesker Brothers on Public Square South and at 109 S. Main St.
• Pulaski: Mesker Brothers at 114 S. First St. and 108–110 N. Second St.

These are database listings that haven't been checked on site, and the database may use older street numbers. One of the listed numbers, 125 E. Market in Fayetteville, is today's number for a building damaged in the February 2026 fire.

"Tin" ceilings

Pressed-metal ceilings were on the market by the early 1870s and spread fast in the 1880s and 1890s. They were cheap, quick to put up and looked like fancy plaster. Most "tin" ceilings were actually thin steel, stamped into panels, often 24 inches square, and nailed to wood furring strips. Many storefronts on our squares got them. [NPS Preservation Brief 49]

Tools: ropes, poles and muscle

None of this used engines on the job site. Builders relied on a few simple tools:

• Scaffolding of poles lashed or nailed together, raised a story at a time as the walls went up.
• Hods and ramps. Brick and mortar went up on a laborer's shoulder in a hod, by ladder or plank ramp.
• Gin pole, block and tackle. One tall pole held up by guy ropes, with pulleys at the top, could lift heavy timbers, cut stone sills and cast-iron columns into place. A team, a mule or a hand winch pulled the rope.

We haven't found a construction photo of any of our four courthouses yet that we can show here. The picture below is a general example of the same method; if you have a photo of one of our courthouses going up, see the “Photo wanted” cards above.

Fire, storm and rebuilding

1. 1813–14 log Pulaski: the log courthouse burns, "presumably" set by impatient citizens. [Goodspeed 1886, Giles, pp. 754-755]
2. 1830 brick Shelbyville: a tornado destroys the brick courthouse. [Goodspeed 1887, Bedford, pp. 865-867]
3. 1856 brick Pulaski: the new courthouse burns from a faulty flue. [NRHP 83003033]
4. 1863 brick Shelbyville: soldiers quartered in the courthouse set it on fire by accident. [Goodspeed 1887, Bedford, pp. 865-867]
5. 1883 frame Lynchburg: the Christian Church, then used as the courthouse, burns. [Goodspeed 1886, Moore, p. 809]
6. 1907 brick Pulaski: the 1859 Heiman courthouse burns. [NRHP 83003033]
7. 1913 frame Lynchburg: the frame east and south sides of the square burn, and are rebuilt in brick. [NRHP 96000771]
8. 1934 brick Shelbyville: a mob burns the courthouse. The brick shell is reused in 1935–36. [Rutherford Co. Historical Society] [TSLA/TeVA, Marr & Holman plans]
9. 2026 today Fayetteville: fire on the south side of the square spreads building to building through hidden voids in the old walls and floors. [WZDX/RocketCityNow, Feb. 8, 2026]

Look at the fires above. Wooden buildings, wooden towers and stoves were the risk. Brick walls, stone and later concrete were how towns fought back: Lynchburg's 1913 fire stopped at a bank's concrete walls. The same old construction, with wood floors and open spaces hidden between shared brick walls, is why fire can still move along a row of 1800s buildings today. [NRHP 96000771] [WZDX/RocketCityNow, Feb. 8, 2026]

Main sources: Goodspeed’s History of Tennessee (1886–87); National Register of Historic Places nominations (NPGallery); NPS Preservation Briefs 2, 26, 27 and 49; Library of Congress Sanborn maps, HABS and FSA collections; Tennessee State Library & Archives; Tennessee Encyclopedia. Spot a mistake or know more? Email hello@ourtownalmanac.com.